Review: Romancing Miss Bronte As a reviewer I truly believe one of the hardest tasks a writer can undertake is to tell a story that readers already know the ending of.  It takes skill and talent to keep someone enthralled by a tale that they know will end badly.  Thus the story of the Bronte siblings is especially hard because of their tragic and cruel fates for such talented writers so ahead of their time. However Juliet Gael not only has taken on the challenge but also succeeded in doing a decent job of making it an interesting and inventive narrative.

In Gael’s Romancing Miss Bronte, we receive an intimate look into the life of Charlotte Bronte including her family, short lived romance and of course the writing of Jane Eyre.  Focusing on the courtship of Charlotte by her father’s curate Arthur Nicholls, Gale also manages to weave a tale of the Bronte’s sisters secretly published works and everyday familial life.  While the book is interesting in the way that it makes Charlotte a character and a woman, it sometimes lacks the spark of life and can read more like a highly researched biographical piece.  Somehow the characters lack fire at times and the deaths of the siblings is detailed in a very offhand manner missing the true experience of ache and longing Charlotte must have surely felt.

However a redeeming factor in the book is the narrative of the struggle Charlotte Bronte made in whether or not to accept romance in her life.  After writing one of the best love stories in literary history could she really settle for such polite affections and a less than advantageous marriage?  This inner turmoil and the outer disagreement with her father to the match create a lively and engrossing narrative not seen in the early chapters.   It is redeeming for the book and makes the ending of much greater emotional interest to the reader.

Romancing Miss Bronte while not exhibiting the emotion expected of a biographical fiction of the Brontes still manages to weave a creative narrative that any Bronte fan will enjoy and want to eagerly read. The book also will educate many readers and fans on the finer points of the lives of the Bronte siblings, which are not common knowledge. All in all Gael has presented a fine read for literary enthusiasts and Bronte fans alike.

And now for a personal confession while I myself am a dedicated Jane Austen fan, she is my most beloved author of all time….my most beloved book is Jane Eyre. I read it at least twice a year, it’s like a comforting friend to me. Perhaps that is why I was so critical of this work. I had very high expectations and I am protective of both dear Charlotte and her works.

For more information on the Bronte siblings and all things Bronte, I recommend The Bronte Blog, a wonderful site that keeps up with the latest news and works connected to Charlotte, Emily and Anne Bronte.


Filed under Adult Books, Classic Literature, historical fiction, New Books

8 responses to “Review: Romancing Miss Bronte

  1. Great review.

    I wonder if Charlotte’s love troubles aren’t another example of writers being terrible lovers. Perhaps we see what love can be to clearly and are always disappointed by what it is.

    • stilettostorytime

      I think to a degree since we must be dreamers to write, that is true. Some accept that love is never to be the fairytale we may write…although it may not be the hell some write of as well…better to love to your best degree than not to love at all I say, can’t say really if Charlotte would regret it or not…only she would know but she took the chance and that’s half the battle. Looked for you in Starbucks today…maybe another time!

      • Ah I agree. Love’s the better choice, even when you end up getting screwed.

        I’m usually chained to my cubicle during the week hehe. I’ll be there this weekend 🙂

  2. I am totally with you! I love Jane Austen but one of my favorite books of all time is Jane Eyre. I just reread it earlier this year, it still amazes me how talented Charlotte Bronte was.

  3. Meg

    I absolutely loved reading Jane Eyre as a teen and had high hopes for Romancing Miss Bronte, but alas — it wasn’t for me. Glad you enjoyed it much more than I did! 🙂

  4. You know how nuts I am about Jane Eyre. I wanted to read this, but came across not-so-favorable reviews–most of them dwelling on the problems you encountered: the lifelessness, the unemotionalness of it, at times.

    But I’ll probably relent and read this one, if I come across it. Anything for Charlotte, I suppose? 🙂

    PS — There’s going to be a readalong of Jane on the 23rd. 🙂

  5. I didn’t even know this book existed. I absolutely love Jane Eyre and have written many papers for school on the subject of Charlotte Bronte and Jane Eyre. Great review! It is now on my reading list! As well as your blog!

    • stilettostorytime

      Thanks Colleen! Welcome…I am a big Bronte and Austen fan so you will see quite a bit of content on both!

Let's Talk....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s